[PREV - TASTE_FOR_DEATH]    [TOP]

BRAIN_PULP


                                                 August 19, 2004

I didn't like
"Pulp Fiction"    It took a year or so
that much when    of thinking about it
I saw it.         before I think I
                  finally got it.


             One thing that seemed weird
             to me is that it really                     John Dickson Carr on
             wasn't very much like                       the pulp magazine:
             actual pulp fiction.
                                                              "Cheap only in
                   Real pulp was a very                       being moderately
                   romantic fiction, often                    priced it
                   about vigilante justice,                   provided
                   but the framework                          excitement for
                   remained one of honorable                  the youthful or
                   heroes fighting to right                   the stay-at-home,
                   the wrongs of the world.                   instilling a
                                                              morality as rigid
                            Always "fighting crime",          as any Sunday
                            though the main character         School's."
                            may himself have been
                            "outside the law".

                                   For them, crime was
                                   not a technical       There are crimes
                                   legal category...     against Humanity
  The film "Pulp Fiction"                                and crimes
  is a story of sleazy                                   against God, and
  gangsters being sleazy                                 sometimes the
  without much in the way                                legal system
  of good guys being good.                               itself is one
                                                         such crime.
          It's a much more
          modern kind of        (Or maybe:                      We are
          story, having         "Pulp" confused                 raised
          little to do with     with "Noir"?)                   on tales
          the pulp of the                                       of anarchy...
          30s and 40s.
                                                                ANARCHY
                       One touch that did
                       make sense though,
                       was the way the
                       John Travolta
 I didn't get it       character was
 until much, much      always reading a
 later: "Pulp          Modesty Blaise
 Fiction" is a         novel in the bathroom.
 story about
 people ruled by                             Modesty Blaise,
 fantasies and                               now *that's* pulp.
 pretentions.                                                    BLAZING
                                             Tarentino is
     It's not intended                       supposedly
     to be pulp                              interested in
     fiction itself,                         trying to do a
     rather it's about                       film version of
     people with "pulp                       Modesty Blaise,
     fiction" stuck in                       which would be
     their heads,          brain             interesting to
     people who are        pulp              see...
     trying to write       fiction
     themselves into                              I'm not holding
     stories.                                     my breath.  That
                                                  seems like one
     And there's a                                of the great
     strong suggestion                            doomed projects.
     that the Bible is
     just another                                     None of the other
     example of Pulp.                                 attempts at
                                                      translating it
     But the reasons                                  to film have
     everyone loved                                   gotten anywhere
     this movie (and                                  near the mark.
     the reasons I
     didn't) have                                       MY_NAME_IS_MODESTY
     little to do
     with this.

     On the surface,
     this is a story
     featuring
     completely
     worthless,          We used
     contemptible        to call these
     villains as main    "anti-heroes".
     characters...

     I think that's
     what people         (Well... that and
     like about it.      the sound track.)

     Once anathema,
     now contemporary
     America laps
     this stuff up.                       Whatever that
                                          means: anathema?

                                            Against theme?
              I hate to sound all
              goody-two-shoes, but                 ANATHEMA
              this worries me.



                                        An even more prime example
                                        was "The Silence of the Lambs"

                                        I knew people who took the
                                        Hannibal Lecter character as
Well, there have always been            some sort of existential
some fairly twisted subtexts            anti-hero, demonstrating his
to popular fiction if you               superiority to the, uh,
look closely...  The formula            sheep-like masses.
used to be that you could
write stories about nasty               But it seems obvious to me that if
main characters all you want,           he were *really* superior he wouldn't
*provided* that they met                be playing these stupid games.  The
with Bad Ends (however                  Superior Man does not go around
perfunctory and unconvincing            murdering inferiors for fun.
those ends might have been).

   The villains have
   often been screens on
   which to project the
   inner desires of the            An example of this sort of
   audience.                       thing is "Basic Instinct",
                                   where people couldn't even    Sharon Stone
      The worrying thing is        be bothered to *tsk tsk*      claiming that
      that it's no longer          about the villainess-hero.    they tricked
      considered a                                               her into
      requirement to keep             Well, I guess in           doing a slit
      this stuff under                some circles there         shot: that
      wraps.  It's now just           was some sort of           struck me as
      assumed as an obvious           controversy about          a nice cover
      fact that of course             it being anti-gay,         story.
      we'd all really like            but that's silly.
      to be vicious killers,                                     The next thing
      if only we could get            She was evil and           you know women
      away with it.                   bisexual.  So you          will be
                                      could try to spin          "accidentally"
        (Hence, SUV sales.)           this as being              flashing their
                                      anti-bisexual,             tits on
                                      except that                television.
                                      everyone seemed
But then, even before this            to want to *be*            Is it an
trend, it's always been a             her.  So I think           encouraging
puzzle to me how people can           they missed the            sign that
survive on a staple diet of           point.                     they feel
morality plays of one sort                                       the need to
or another, and then just             (Sure, the Michael         indulge in
walk away from it and go              Douglas character          this
back to living their                  said some nasty            hypocrisy?
whatever-I-can-get-away-with          things to a lesbian,
lives.                                but they weren't all         Weak props
                                      that nasty really,           for slim
   There's some sort of               and he was a chump           hopes...
   "don't try this at                 any way.)
   home" label stuck on
   all aspects of fiction.

      So I really shouldn't
      exaggerate the
      importance of the
      influence of fictional
      on the real.

         We might be be better off
         if it had more influence.
                                           And of course:
         TWISTED_PATHS
                                           It doesn't bother me if us
                                           intellectuals feel like in
                                           indulging in anti-social
                                           fantasies and Naked Lunches.

                                              I worry that the
                                              benighted masses
                                              might not be be
                                              able to handle it.



--------
[NEXT - THUNDER]