[PREV - SIXLIMB]    [TOP]

UTOPIA

Ursula LeGuin's only good work
is a short piece that plays
with our gut-level perception
that a perfect society is
impossible.  She describes an
idyllic place named Omelas,                A joke from usenet: 	 
repeatedly harping on how it               If an imperfect utopia is an omelas,
all seems like a fairy tale.               then a small imperfect utopia 
Finally, she adds one last                 must be an "omelette".
element to the scenario: a                    
suffering child locked away                It took me a while to get it,
in a closet, and *then* it all             but the word "omelette" is   
seems much more realistic.                 probably the source of       
                                           LeGuin's word Omelas (just as
                                           "Earth" was mutated into 
Once I considered			   "Urras" in the Dispossesed): 
myself one of "The Ones Who		                               
Walk Away From Omelas", but		      You can't make an omelette  
I've long since wandered back		      without breaking a few eggs. 
to it.						        		   
                                                         
                                                   (Though LeGuin says      
                                                    that it's just           
                                                    from a highway         
                                                    sign: "Salem, O"  
                                                    spelled backwards.) 
                                                   
                                                                               



    From Brian Eno's "A Year With Swollen Appendices": 
						       
						       
    At lunch discussing comparative philosophical systems.  
    Bono maintains Judaeo-Christianity shows good results.  
    I say it's a question of what number and type of casualties 
    you're willing to tolerate (arrange various philosophies
    along such axes).  Some systems produce only total
    losers and flat-out winners -- the banana republic
    model -- while others attempt a 'spread it evenly'
    approach -- welfare-stately.  Is 'scapegoatism' -- a big
    feature of many 'primitive' societies -- a way of trying
    to visit all current psychological distress on to just
    one person?  And, if so, how do we feel about that kind
    of deal -- where one person suffers enormously in lieu
    of everyone else?  Is this the basis of torture and The
    Ordeals?
	    

------

[NEXT - PROVIDENCE]