[PREV - STYLISH_HAND]    [TOP]

WEB_VESTIBULE


                                             September 13, 2018
                                                         
From some material                                       
originally included in                                   
                                                         
   STYLISH_HAND          
                                                         
I've got reservations about it these days, but there was an idea
in "web design" that I used to like where rather than having a
proliferation of links to external pages, each such link would go
to a "vestibule" page that would have some short         
description/discussion about the link.                   
                                                         
I thought I might do this with the "doomfiles" also:     
                                                         
Rather than go directly to the external                  
location, they'll do an internal html                    
jump into a special doomfiles                            
"vestibule" page (possibly called                        
REFERENCES, or THE_OUT_DOOR).  This                      
page will contain a listing of live                      
external links, with brief discussion/                   
description of what the links point to.                  
                                                         
The purpose of the "Vestibule" approach         It's something like this:
is a little hard to put in words, but                    
I've experimented with it in other web             Promiscuously linked
pages (notably my San Francisco guide)             webs can be discon-
and I like the way it works.                       certingly fuzzy.
                                                         
    (In some respects, it's                          Click-click-click
    better for *each page*                           and you pass
    to have it's own vestibule,                      rapidly through
    but this would disrupt the                       multiple topics
    doomfiles "browse sequence"                      and points-of-view.
    too much.)                                           
                                                         
                                                     With this
                                                     cluster of pages
                                                     ("the doomfiles")
                                                     you're supposed
  There's a real problem with the                    to know you're
  usual practice with web links:                     in one place,
  a link to a page shows up as a                     listening to one
  few highlighted words.  These                      voice.
  words typically give you a                             
  *hint* about where the link                        When you follow
  goes, but don't really say very                    an external link,
  much.                                              if you need to
                                                     go through the
  Compare that to the print                          "vestibule" on the
  media version of a link, the                       way out, it
  footnote, where any amount of                      underlines the
  commentary about a reference                       fact that you're
  is allowed:                                        leaving, it
                                                     highlights
  You can describe what kind of                      the boundary.
  work it is, express                                    
  reservations about some aspects                       Further, once
  of it, list authors and dates                         you're used to
  of publication, etc.  The                             it, it makes
  footnote gives you information                        possible a
  you can use to decide whether                         different style
  you'll follow the reference.                          of reading, you
                                                        can defer
                                                        following a
  Clicking on a link is far                             link because
  less time-consuming that                              you know you
  following a print-media                               can find it
  reference, but nevertheless                           below in the
  it does consume some time and                         "vestibule",
  effort, and many people just                          which acts as a
  skip them out of habit.                               "see also"
                                                        section.
                                                         
                                                          And the
                                                          vestibule itself
                                                          can be an
                                                          interesting
                                                          page to read
                                                          through.
                                                         
       One of the big reasons I'm having                                            
       second thoughts these days is the                                            
       proliferation of stupid javascript                                           
       tricks like a pop-up that says                                               
       "You are leaving our absolutely                                             
       wunnerful site!  Are you sure you         
       want to, you crazy you?"                  
                                                 
                                                 
           There's much to be said               
           for Standard Behavior.                
                                                                                 
                                                                                 
                                                                                 




--------
[NEXT - WELL-QUALIFIED]