[PREV - FUSED_CORE]    [TOP]

IRONTHORN


                                        August 27, 1992 


There's this Algis Budrys novel,               The published title was 
a crazy piece of work on the face              "The Amsirs & the Iron Thorn".
of it.  There are these people trapped                                
on Mars, for generations living a grim         The author's intended  
desperate existence where everthing they       title was simply       
do has to be oriented toward survival,         "The Iron Thorn".      
and practically nothing but survial.                
                                                    UNDESERVED_TITLES
Because of this the life they live                  
seems pointless, without meaning.                            
                                                             
Then midway through the book, there's                        
this crazy shift: the main character                         
stumbles into a working space ship that                      
takes him to earth... a utopian earth,                       
where all physical needs are met,             "...and you shall not
and nothing is left for anyone to                 want more..."
do except play with fashions,
create artwork, go to parties...

And because no one has to do
anything, their lives seem
pointless, without meaning.



                              Idiotic Interpretation #1:
                              Budrys is saying that
                              life is meaningless.

                              Closer to the point:
                              The things that give life
                              meaning are not at all
                              understood.
        
                                                  LIFE                     
                                                                           
        Sometimes, people take                                             
        the attitude that fiction                  "It is only where men are 
        shouldn't have a "message";                to be found neither too 
        if you've got a didactic                   rich and powerful to be 
        point to make, why not                     tempted into extravagant 
        write an essay?                            indulgences nor too poor 
                                                   and limited to care for 
        The _Iron Thorn_ is an                     anything beyond the daily 
        example of why not...                      need that those 
        the texture of life is                     disinterested curiosities 
        what the book is about;                    and serene impulses can 
        the reader's reactions to                  have play that give sane 
        the two extreme scenarios                  philosophy and science 
        that are presented are                     and great art to the 
        crucial to the philosophic                 world ...  "         
        point.                                        
                                                      -- H.G. Wells, 
                                                      "The Outline of History",
                                                      Chapter 29, Section 3,   
                                                      page 506                 
                                                                               
                          The Iron Thorn is
                          a necessary pain.
                                                         
                                                                           
                                                                           
                                                  


--------
[NEXT - SUNY]