[PREV - HOLY_COATS_OF_BLACK]    [TOP]

MUSICAL_DAMAGE


                                      October 25, 2003

One more time:

Same as it ever was, 
or deep decadent decline?

I don't think there's much question that
popular music is in bad shape... in fact,
isn't it interesting that there isn't
that much question that something *has*
been lost?

You might take a line like
"it's all just a matter of
taste, if you like it you
like it, what right have we
to judge?"
          
But whenever we're confronted
with the hit of the moment, we
know immediately that we're   
not looking at another        
Doors, Who, or Airplane let          
alone another Beatles.               Or even a     
                                     Talking Heads.
              Clearly some things
              are very different.
                   
                     The music industry is now capable  
                     of manufacturing pre-fab megahits  
                     (Britany, etc)... *but* these have   
                     no staying power.                     No one cares about
                                                           "New Kids on the  
                     But the recording labels make         Block" now that   
                     most of their money on their          they're old.      
                     back catalog, and their      
                     current mega-hits will never 
                     be worth anything in later   
                     decades.                     
                                                       
                        They've dug themselves into 
                        a serious hole: they can make 
                        a lot of money, but they need 
                        to spend a lot of money to do 
                        it, and *all* of their return 
                        on that investment has to happen 
                        quickly.                                 
                        
                                         This is their central trouble:  
                                         internet file-trading is just   
                                         not having that big an effect on
                                         their bottom line -- at least   
                                         not yet.                        
                                                     
Walking around in                  
public, I hear a lot                     
of very retro-music:                                                    
20 to 30 years old.                                                
It really wasn't like                                              
this back when that                                                
music was new.  If                                                 
you went out to a bar                
in 1975, you did not              Caveat: there *was* the    
hear Frank Sinatra on             musak plague of the                         
the jukebox.                      70s.  For those of you                      
                                  who are uninitiated,                        
In the 60s, (and to               Musak was a company                         
*some extent* in the              that claimed to have    
70s and 80s) it was               scientifically designed        
possible* for                     a format of                 You couldn't 
authentic, creative               easy-listening              go out to a 
music to get a major              wallpaper in the form       supermarket in 
label contract.                   of symphonic versions       the 70s 
                                  of popular songs.           without 
Major labels were willing                                     drowning in 
to experiment with                   Though I guess in        Musak.  Now 
different trends in the              these post-Chronos       you're more 
hopes of *discovering* the           Quartet days this        likely to hear 
next big thing (rather               kind of thing is         a "light rock"
than manufacturing it).              standard operating       station.      
                                     procedure in the                        
                                     "classical" world,   
Disco, 70s punk, and new             e.g. symphonic        
wave were *all* picked up and        "tributes" to Black
pushed by the majors though          Sabbath.               
sometimes -- often? --               
without much in the way of              I'm skeptical of 
return on their investment.             this trend, but     
                                        still, the worst   
   So they gave up.                     of these are much   
                                        better than Musak    
      Columbia is not going             was.                                  
      to be discovering any                                                   
      more Leonard Cohens.                  
                                  
          It looks like something is                       
          fundamentally broken in                          
          our culture.                                     
                                                           
             The music sucks because most people really
             don't care about it very much, which in
             itself might not be much of a problem, but
             they don't seem to care a lot about much of
             anything else either.
                                  
                                                              
                                  
  Of course, this is the          
  standard geezer lament:         
                                  
    Gee, back in our day were we really as   
    stupid as the kids are now?  We were   
    certainly pretty stupid, but aren't   
    they even worse now?                  
                                  
         Call me self-deluded if you like,
         but I think they've finally      
         achieved perma-stupid.           
                                  
            But then there's a possibility that 
            future decades will look back on    
            this era as a passing phase, a "New 
            Fifties": Lost in xenophobia; a     
            dangerous lack of respect for core  
            civic values (freedom, democracy);  
            pop culture stagnant, creativity    
            driven way underground...  Thank god
            decades are only ten years long, eh?
                                                

--------
[NEXT - PISTOL_WHIPPED]