[PREV - INTO_THE_STRAW]    [TOP]

NELSON


                                       early 90s    Additonal: March 2000
Attending Ted Nelson's 
_World Enough_ talks...
                                                            
I begin to pick up          And I begin to wonder:          
something about             Is it really a productive       
his methods.                way to work?

One of the things he really         You can drive yourself
wants Xanadu for is to              crazy doing this!  Far
handle the intercomparision         better to try to get
of different versions.  He          it right the first
wants to be able to look at         time, to develop an        You can't
things every way, before            instinct for picking a     write an
deciding which way is best.         good way without           essay the
                                    trying to exhaustively     way a
                                    examine all                computer 
                                    permutations.              plays chess. 
 
                                                                      META 
He also places a lot of             But who is ever 
emphasis on methods of              going to look at 
historical backtrack, so            those old 
that you can look at older          versions, except 
versions of what you have,          for Lit majors, 
and so on.                          historians, and 
                                    masochists?           I wonder what 
                                    Very rarely is        Nelson would 
                                    this a useful         think of a GUI 
                                    feature.              editor with a 
                                                          simple, 
				                          integrated 
				                          interface to a 
				                          programmer's 
				                          version control 
                                                          system, like 
                                                          CVS?  (Suggest 
Also, evidentally Nelson            Drowning              for Lyx?) 
takes endless amounts of            yourself in               
notes about things, to              notes is a bad          (January 27, 2006) 
the point where he can't            idea.  You              Now, the wikipedia 
keep track of where the             should always           has some "History" 
old notes are, or what              try to work on          features like this.
they're about.                      something close 
       	  			    to the finished 
	  			    product (if at 
				    all possible)               FINISHED 
                                    rather than 
                                    stall by taking 
                                    yet another 
                                    note. 
                                                          BOTTOMSUP 
 
He puts a lot of emphasis          But, If the idea 
on inspiration, getting            is really good, won't 
that idea down on paper            you remember it, or 
before it's lost.                  at least be able to re- 
                                   discover it without 
                                   much trouble? 
 
 
 
                  Taking an unsympathetic eye, 
                  Ted Nelson looks an awful lot    
                  like a plodder, a slow           Though I'm sure you could
                  thinker with a weak memory.      find people who would say
                                                   similar things about me. 
                                                                            
                                                       EXTERNAL                     
                       It's actually a real problem                         
                       that there's no shortage of       
                       unsympathetic eyes towards Nelson.
                                                                   
                              Despite the lack of success of his   
                              software project, his books have     
                              been a clear influence on the        
                              current world of webs and browsers...
                              and the software we've got might     
                              be a lot better if he'd had an       
                              even bigger audience.                
                                                                   
                                         Tim Berners-Lee calls him 
                                         a "professional visionary".
                                                                    
 
                                            And there was a Wall 
                                            Street Journal       
                                            headline: "Japanese  
                                            Embrace a Man Too    
                                            Eccentric For Silicon
                                            Valley."             
                                                                           
 
 
 
--------
[NEXT - BOTTOMSUP]