[PREV - KDRAMA_RECS]    [TOP]

KDRAMA_TRACING


                                                            May 17, 2018
                                                            May  9, 2019
A friend asked us which Korean
drama's we'd been watching--                She thought it was weird we
                                            hadn't seen the Goblin yet--
Just then we'd been watching                (a point quickly remedied).
"The Legend of the Blue Sea" (a mermaid
goes to Seoul)-- this is a show that              I sometimes trace strange
works fairly well, though it has a                paths through things, and in
definite fish-out-of-water problem.               this case it was a long time
There aren't a lot of good locations in           before it even occured to me
Seoul to transform into a mermaid, so as          to consult any sort of fan
the show progresses that aspect has to            pages or popularity stats.
fade, and her secondary power of memory
manipulation becomes more critical.
                                           Series concept:
I got interested in checking this one      an invasion of extraterrestrials
out because the screenwriter and           armed with amnesia ray guns--
female lead were the same as on            they generate kdrama plots
another show I'd seen "My Love From        whereever they go.
Another Star".

            written: Park Ji-Eun              The male lead in "Legend"
            actress: Gianna Jun               was Lee Min-Ho, who
                                              was also the lead in
And that show is okay, though it              "The Heirs", playing
also has problems: the lead                   opposite Park Shin-hye.   
characters aren't very sympathetic
and the fantastic premises involved               "The Heirs" was, as I remember it
(a stranded alien dude with super                 watchable, though not too much was
powers, etc) were a bit of a mess.                memorable about it: it's premise
                                                  involved a girl dealing with rich
Another one I liked quite a bit recently          boy bullies, no doubt an echo of an
was "Oh My Ghost", about a pathologically         earlier show that Lee Min-Ho was
shy girl who can see ghosts and who is            also cast in, the Korean adaptation
possessed by a female ghost with a                of the manga "Boys Over Flowers"
radically different personality.                  (which I've read, though I've so
The ghost immediately goes to work trying         far passed on the video versions).
to seduce the boss at the restaurant where
she works: this is a virgin ghost who is              For me, Park Shin-hye
convinced that she needs appropriate                   was one of the original
sexual experience before she can finally               faces of Kdrama-land:
pass on.  This show has some of the best
acting I've seen anywhere, in any                      "He's Beautiful" (2009)
context-- Park Bo Young plays two                      "Flower Boys Next Door" (2013)
radically different characters, and both               "Goong S"  (2006)
of them evolve as the story progresses.                "The Heirs" (2013)
                                                       "Pinocchio" (2014)

          OH_MY_GHOST
                                   
I found "Strong Girl do Bong           
Song"-- also starring Park Bo                 In "He's Beautiful" a trainee nun
Young-- pretty remarkable, though             has a twin brother with an
not always in good ways.  She                 opportunity to join the famous
plays a young woman from a family             boy-band "A.N. Gel"-- her brother    
where the women are essentially               is hung-up in the US with a minor    
super-strong warriors of heaven.              medical issue, so his sister is      
This show is peculiar in it's                 drafted to temporarily take his      
weirdly barbaric sense of humor:              place, secretly cross-dressing to    
Our heroine punches out a ganster             pass for male.  At which point,      
dude early on and we see the                  every member of "A.N. Gel" starts
teeth flying out of his mouth, and            falling in love with her.               
then throughout the rest of the             
series his mangled mouth is played                BAD_GIRLS_FATE
for "laughs": he drools, can't              
talk right, his false teeth drop                  WHERE_ANGELS_GO_NUN_FOLLOWS
out when he's surprised...                  
                                            
   STRONG_GIRL_DO_BONG_SOON


Another show that comes to
mind is "My Girlfriend is a       Both "He's
Nine-Tailed Fox" (2010) with      Beautiful"
Shin Min-ah playing a             and "Nine       This cross-dressing plot was
Gumiho-- a super-strong           Tailed"         no doubt inspired by the very
"magical girlfriend"              were written    popular "Coffee Prince" (2007)
who is ignorant of the ways       by the Hong     where Yoon Eun-hye plays a
of the modern world, and          Sisters         young woman passes for male to
obsessed with eating beef.        team.           get a job as one of the coffee
                                                  princes of the title-- you'll
                                                  be surprised to hear her boss
                                                  finds himself falling in love
                                                  with him/her and feels very
                                                  confused about it.
                               COFFEE_PRINCE
                                                  I've haven't seen too much
                                                  else of Yoon Eun-hye, who's
                         The premise of the       career has been a mess of
                         show "Goong S"           management disputes, legal
                         involves an              hassles and physical attacks
                         alternate history,       from "antifans"-- but I
                         showing a modern         thought she was good in the
                         Korea that still has     oddly grim movie "Little Black
                         a royal family--         Dress" (2011).  The year
                         this premise was         before Coffee Prince she was
                         first used in "The       in a show that was supposed to
                         Princess Hours".         be a big deal, which I haven't
                                                  seen yet: "Princess Hours"
       "Goong S" is about a young punk            (2006).
       who works doing Ramen delivery
       and who turns out to secretly be              (From "Princess Hours"
       the son of a prince: he is                    to "Coffee Prince".
       brought into a world of palace                The rules of pop
       intrigue, where Park Shin-hye is              culture are the same
       a "just a servant", and yet he                everywhere.)
       has more in common with her than
       the royals

    Then there's a Park Shin-hye show        The male lead in "Coffee Prince"
    that I liked quite a bit, where          was Gong Yoo, who was also the
    she plays a reclusive woman who          lead actor in "The Goblin".  The
    happens to live next door to a           main female lead was Kim Go-Eun,
    manga artist, and a triangle             though she's been somewhat
    develops between him and a               neglected because much of the
    flamboyant young genius of video         public buzz that I've heard
    game design.  Let's see, that one        revolves around the Second Couple
    was...  Ah: "Flower Boys Next            in that show, played by Lee Dong
    Door".                                   Wook and Yoo In-Na.

    I had the title confused with a                              WOOKSTER
    half-dozen other things-- the manga
    "Boys Over Flowers" and more on topic       But perhaps the key thing
    "Shut Up Flower Boy Band", a show           about the Goblin was the
    about tough-guy teenagers who form a        screenwriter, Kim Eun-Sook
    band "Eye Candy" who's success is cut       (aka KES) who working with
    short by a number of problems of            the director Lee Eung-Bok
    varying degrees of plausibility.            knocked out three major
                                                hits in a row:

                                                "Descendents of the Sun"
                                                "Goblin" and "Mr. Sunshine"
And I almost forgot "Pinnochio" in which
Park Shin-hye plays a woman who wants to        DESCENDANTS_OF_THE_SUN  GOBLIN
become an investigative journalist but is
hampered by a bad case of the (fictional)       The two of them have the
"Pinnochio Syndrome": whenever she tries        budget clout to do anything
to lie, she begins hiccuping furiously.         at this point ($28M on Mr.
                                                Sunshine), but seem to be
   There's an anti-fan or two I see on          taking a break now (2019).
   the net that always wants to argue
   that Park Shin-hye isn't that great          And before working with
   an actress, but I refer you to this          that director, KES had
   show where she needs to be able to           a number of other hits
   do things like furiously hiccupping          to her credit like
   while she's crying.                          "The Heirs" and
                                                "Secret Garden" (2010).
   And in general there's something to
   be said for understated, naturalistic        "The Secret Garden" is a
   comic acting -- "He's Beautiful" is          body-swapper: the female lead,
   way better than the more broadly             played by Ha Ji-won, works as a
   acted Japanese remake, if you ask me.        very athletic stunt woman who
                                                ends up getting involved with a
                                                bratty rich boy-- they're handed
I'm far from caught up on the history           some bottles of magic wine
of the Hallyu, but I am up to the               that creates an odd condition
point where I often see new ones as             where their personalities swap
they come out, such as:                         bodies if they're caught in the
                                                rain.
  "Because This Is My First Life" (2017)
                                                            SECRET_GARDEN
  A beginning television script-writer
  needs to find a place to live in              From there I stepped back in
  Seoul without much money to work              time to an earlier Ha Ji-Won
  with-- she gets taken on as a roomate         show, "What Happened in Bali?"
  by a man before either of them                (2004) and was somewhat
  realize that they're not the same             suprised at it's rather bleak
  gender.  They eventually get married          treatment of the Cinderella
  in-name-only, just to provide a               theme.
  socially acceptable excuse for this
  arrangement.   There are other                   WHAT_HAPPENED_IN_BALI
  pairs of couples on stage that
  illustrate a number of different
  attitudes to love and marriage..              The reddit kdrama group tends
                                                to focus a lot on recent
  I was initially enthusiastic about            releases-- resisting that
  this one, but it stumbles in the last         influence, at one point I
  few episodes.                                 intentionally picked an older
                                                one at random: "Star's Lovers".
                       FIRST_LIFE               The male lead is a serious
                                                writer and academic, but he
                                                gets roped in to doing a
  "Beauty Inside" (2018)                        ghost-writing job for a famous
                                                actress.   This gradually
  This was something like the third remake      leads to them getting involved
  of this premise (I've seen none of the        together in a way that doesn't
  predecessors):                                feel too forced.

  The female lead is a Famous Actress, but        You've got some serious nerd
  she has a strange mystical affliction:          fantasy here: famous actress
  periodically her body transforms and she        barges into your rooftop
  looks completely different-- she has to         apartment because she needs
  go into hiding for a week or so until she       to hide out somewhere, and
  gets over it and returns to her usual           she wants to lie around on
  state.                                          your bed reading books.

  Whenever she wakes and discovers she has        This has a few good episodes,
  someone else's form, she records a short        but hits a wall where people
  video of herself, reciting:                     sit around looking morose for
                                                  a half-dozen episodes.
    "I am Han Se Gye-- and this is it."
                                                  One of it's main assets is
  The female lead Seo Hyun-Jin played             the elfin smile of the
  opposite Lee Min-Ki, who played a               female lead: Choi Ji-woo,
  somewhat similar character in the               who I later realized had
  aforementioned "First Life", a guy              been the lead in the
  with some Aspberger's-like issues.              legendary "Winter Sonata"
  (and it's interesting seeing him in             (2002):
  something like "Spellbound"-- aka
  "My Curse At Girlfriend" (?)--                     WINTER_SONATA
  where he plays an effusive, smiling
  fellow.


  "Suits" (2018)

  A Korean re-make of a US production, about a           It's pretty typical of
  genius-level kid without a law degree who ends         me to have only seen
  up passing as an entry-level lawyer at a slick         the Korean version of
  firm.  This is very much a male-buddy story            something.
  about the relationship between this kid and the
  older lawyer who takes him on in spite of the               BEL_AMI
  irregular background.  Some decent schtick here
  and there, and sometimes it's not always so               (If they ever do a 
  nonsensical that it's distracting.                        re-make of "Game of   
                                                            Thrones", maybe I'll
                                                            sit through it--
  "You're All Surrounded" (2014)                            they'd probably
                                                            tighten it up.)
  A cop show with occasional moments, but too few.
  The male lead is so dismissive of the female lead
  it's grating (he repeatedly calls her "bird
  brain").  As is all too typical for a Korean cop
  show, the police seem to think it's a good
  iterrogation move to go: "You did it didn't you!
  Why don't you confess!"   (There is one
  interrogation that's handled more sanely: they
  plan ahead, consult a psychologist, etc.)

     It was good stumbling across Ahn Jae-Hyeon,
     here playing a character almost identical
     to his later role in the show "Beauty Inside".


And then there's one of the best...

  "Avengers Social Club" (2017)

This is a personal favorite that holds up well
on re-viewing... but I'm not at all sure how
I found this one.  I must've just thought the
name looked interesting.
                                                    AVENGERS_SOCIAL_CLUB


                                    So that was a game attempt at
                                    trying to talk about every
                                    Kdrama I've seen... I skipped
                                    a few, though:

                                           "Signal" (2016)
                                           "The Good WItch" (2018)
                                           "Blade Man"
                                           "Touch Your Heart" (2019)
                                           "Little Black Dress" (2011)
                                           "Love Alert" aka
                                             "Fluttering Warning" (2018)
                                           "Cinderella
                                              and the Four Princes" (2016)
                                           "I am Not a Robot"
                                           "Good Chicken"
                                           "Let's Fight Ghost"
                                           "Life On Mars"
                                           "Scent of a Woman"
                                           "Queen In Hyun's Man" (2012)
                                           "Sky Castle" (2018)
                                           "He is Psychometric" (2019)
                                           "Her Private Life" (2019)
                                           "Abyss" (2019)



            Tracing lines through the body of work:          OTA_SPACE

            Actresses, actors, writers, directors,
            thematic keywords, popularity stats...

            And where do these lines lead?

            What might one build with such a network?





--------
[NEXT - OTA_SPACE]